Taylor Swift appeals court ruling amid allegations she stole Shake It Off lyrics

Taylor Swift has appealed a court ruling regarding Shake It Off (Photo: Getty)

Taylor Swift has appealed the decision to hold a trial, amid allegations she stole the lyrics to Shake It Off.

The 32-year-old released the catchy hit in 2014 as the first single from the fifth studio album, 1989.

However, she was faced with claims that she covered some of the lyrics for Playas Gon ‘Play, released by 3LW.

Songwriters Sean Hall and Nate Butler claimed she covered a few lines from the song they wrote for the girl group, which was released in 2001.

Both songs contain the lyrics “gamers will play” and “enemies will hate”.

District Judge Michael Fitzgerald said there were “enough objective similarities” between the two songs for the case to be tried by a jury.

However, attorneys for Taylor called “unprecedented” a US judge’s decision to leave the case in court, asking for it to be reconsidered.

In court documents obtained by Billboard, filed Thursday, they said: “Plaintiffs could sue anyone who writes, sings or publicly says ‘the players are going to play’ and ‘the enemies are going to hate.’

“Allowing this is unprecedented and deceives the public domain.

“Doing it here leaves only this similarity: both works use public domain versions of two short sentences – ‘gamers will play’ and ‘enemies will hate’ – which are free to use for anyone, and two other different tautologies that the complainants claim to share the same underlying general idea or concept.

They argued that the two lyrics did not pass the “extrinsic test” of proving substantial similarity, after a comparison of materials.

Taylor Swift poses backstage at the 2021 BRIT Awards at the O2 Arena on May 11, 2021 in London, England.  (Photo by Dave J Hogan / Getty Images)

Taylor quit Shake It Off in 2014 (Photo: Getty)

“The presence of versions of the two short public domain statements and two other tautologies in both songs… just does not pass the extrinsic test,” the lawyers added in the documents. “The defendants respectfully request the court to reconsider its decision and apply the extrinsic test to the claimed substantial similarity in the lyrics.”

Shake It Off features the lyrics: “Gamers will play, play, play, play, play, and enemies will hate, hate, hate, hate, hate.”

At Playas Gon ‘Play, 3LW – made up of Adrienne Bailon, Kiely Williams and Naturi Naughton, who was later replaced by Jessica Benson in the line-up – sings the lines: “The players, they’re going to play, and the enemies, they will hate it. ‘

The case has dragged on for years, with representatives for Taylor calling the songwriters’ claims “ridiculous” and “nothing more than a financial grab” in 2017.

The judge initially dismissed the case, saying the lyrics were too “unoriginal” to be copyrighted and cited 13 earlier songs that contained similar lyrics.

However, after the writers appealed in 2018, a federal appeals court overturned the judge’s decision, relaunching the trial.

They seek unspecified damages.

Metro.co.uk has reached out to representatives for Taylor for comment.

Do you have a story?

If you have a celebrity story, video or photos, please contact the Metro.co.uk Animation Team by emailing us at celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit page love to hear from you.

MORE: EastEnders star Max Bowden posts cute festive snap with girlfriend

MORE: Justin Hartley Brags About His Relationship With Sofia Pernas After Chrishell Stause Divorce: “It’s Amazing When You Don’t Force It”

american show biz

Source link

Comments are closed.